
Home/Resources/FRP in smelter acid plants
What an Acid-Plant Survey Teaches About Specifying FRP
Many FRP failures in a smelter acid plant trace back to the purchase specification or the installation, not to the material. A survey of the FRP equipment at the PASAR copper smelter in the Philippines (Glencore) found sun-damaged pipe and duct, ducts burnt by a quench-water failure, corroded steel inserts in bolted vessel seams, pump lines without expansion joints, and a purchase standard more than 30 years old. Each finding points to a line that belongs in an FRP specification for a smelter, refinery or mine.
01
The survey: an acid plant with decades of FRP in service
PASAR’s acid plant had a large installed base of FRP pipe, duct, tanks and tower covers, much of it bought to a standard written decades earlier. SBC reviewed the gas-cleaning, weak-acid and cooling areas with the plant team and set out recommendations for the 2018 and 2019 maintenance shutdowns. The findings were not exotic. They are the problems that appear in most plants where FRP has been in service for a long time without an up-to-date purchase and inspection standard:
- Ultraviolet damage. Much of the outdoor pipe and duct showed surface deterioration, worst at field joints and repairs left without UV protection. Without a coating it was also hard to tell new damage from old.
- Burnt duct. The FRP outlet ducts above the humidifying towers had been damaged after quench water was lost: the duct had not been designed for a high-temperature upset.
- Bolted vertical seams. A conical-bottom settler had been built in sections joined with steel-reinforced vertical flanges. The steel inserts and bolts had corroded and the seams were splitting.
- Rigid pump connections. On most weak-acid pumps the expansion joints were missing or in the wrong place, and the lines showed damage from vibration and water hammer at start-up.
- Equipment that could not be inspected. A sump tank had been set in concrete with a fixed cover, so it could not be checked inside or out for leaks.
- Ageing alternatives. Lead-lined steel weak-acid pump tanks had been repaired many times; flat lead tower covers sagged under rain and leaks; steel deck plate corroded where acid and water ponded.
02
From findings to specification lines
Each failure mode maps to a requirement that costs little to write into a purchase order and a great deal to fix in the field.
| Specification item | What to require | What the survey showed |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase standard | Name a current design, fabrication and inspection standard and its edition; require the supplier’s quality-control records and inspection forms for review before shipment. | FRP was still bought to a standard based on technology more than 30 years old. |
| Resin by duty | Either select the resin for each service, or define the operating conditions and let the fabricator propose the materials, with a defects warranty. | Newer resins allowed better matches to each service than the original specification. |
| Upset temperature | State the worst credible upset, such as loss of quench water, not only the normal gas temperature. | Ducts designed for normal operation burnt during an upset. |
| Corrosion barrier | Specify the barrier separately from the structure: at least 2.5 mm under ASME RTP-1, and conductive carbon or graphite veil where heat or static matters. | Replacement duct and tower covers were proposed with carbon veil in the barrier and fire-retardant resin in the structure. |
| Seams and joints | Avoid bolted vertical seams with steel inserts in vessels; require laminated joints with corrosion barrier applied over internal seams. | Corroded steel inserts split a settler’s seams; the recommended repair was to relaminate and add two circumferential ribs. |
| Flexibility | Expansion joints on both sides of pumps and, where needed, at changes of direction. | Pump lines without joints were damaged by vibration and water hammer. |
| UV protection | An exterior UV-resistant coating on outdoor pipe and duct, including field joints, with a colour for each service. | Unprotected joints degraded first, and lines were hard to trace. |
| Drainage and access | Dished rather than flat heads; removable covers; FRP agitator supports; grating instead of plate where liquid can pond. | Flat covers sagged; a buried sump could not be inspected; deck plate corroded under ponded acid. |
| Owner competence | Train a few plant staff in FRP fabrication and inspection so they can review suppliers and monitor equipment. | The survey noted that poor maintenance and installation shorten FRP equipment life. |
03
Which standard, and does the equipment fit inside it?
A named standard only helps if the item is within its scope; check pressure, temperature, size and support spacing before relying on it. International owners’ engineers may cite North American or European documents, so give the edition as well as the name. Fabricating to a standard is a different claim from holding a fabricator certification under it; any certification a project requires is checked for that order.
| Document | Covers | Scope limits to check |
|---|---|---|
| ASME RTP-1 | Stationary FRP vessels for corrosive service | Up to 15 psig (about 1 bar) internal or external pressure; specific design attention above about 82 °C |
| ASTM D3299 / D4097 | Filament-wound / contact-moulded corrosion-resistant tanks | Atmospheric storage |
| SMACNA thermoset FRP duct manual | Duct wall-thickness tables | About 100–1,800 mm diameter, up to 82 °C, supports at about 3 m; larger or hotter duct is calculated per project |
| BS EN 13121 | GRP tanks and vessels; referenced in some supply literature | Confirm the parts and edition that apply |
Vacuum is the condition most often left off the data sheet: pump-out, draining and cooling of hot contents all pull vacuum on a tank that is otherwise atmospheric.
04
Inspection and shipping when the equipment is made in China
When fabrication happens far from the plant, the inspection plan is how the specification gets enforced, so agree hold points and records before production starts. Typical checkpoints are resin and reinforcement records, the approved laminate schedule, corrosion-barrier and wall thickness, cure, flange and nozzle dimensions and orientation, and the specified leak or pressure test. Agree the release document package with the order so it travels with the equipment. Our approach is described under quality control and inspection and inspection and expediting.
Decide early whether each item ships complete or in sections. PASAR’s weak-acid pump tanks were sized to ship complete, which kept field work to setting and connection; very large vessels instead need sectional construction or site work, with the field joints covered by the same inspection plan. Packing, lifting points, sea-fastening and nozzle protection belong in the purchase order. See shipping and export.
05
What PASAR ordered after the survey
Between 2017 and 2021 SBC supplied PASAR with FRP and corrosion-resistant equipment across the acid plant, much of it in the scopes the survey identified.
FRP pump tanks for weak-acid service
FRP pump tanks were ordered in 2019 and 2021. SBC’s 2019 reference records a 47 m³ pump tank, shipped in a packed envelope of 5,100 × 5,100 × 4,300 mm.
Gas-cleaning ductwork, dampers and a humidifying-tower roof
FRP duct was supplied in 2018, 2019 and 2021, with FRP dampers (2018), an FRP demister (2019) and an FRP roof for a humidifying tower (2019).
Pipe spools, grating and lined valves
FRP pipe, fittings and pipe spools were supplied from 2017 to 2020, moulded FRP grating in 2017 and 2019, and 20 PFA- and PTFE-lined valves in 2019.
06
Where FRP was not recommended
A good survey also says where FRP is the wrong answer. PASAR’s humidifying towers take gas at about 300 °C and depend on the spray system; if the sprays fail, the shell sees the full gas temperature. Replacing those towers in FRP was judged possibly not feasible, while an FRP cooling tower downstream was feasible. The same reasoning applies elsewhere: FRP suits hydrochloric acid, chloride-bearing liquors and dilute sulphuric acid, but not pressures above the 15 psig limit of ASME RTP-1, sustained temperatures beyond the resin, or heavy abrasion without a specific design. For abrasive duty see our wear parts and steel process equipment.
07
Buyer questions
Can FRP replace lead-lined steel tanks in a smelter acid plant?
Often, yes, for weak-acid service. At PASAR, SBC recommended replacing lead-lined steel weak-acid pump tanks that had been repaired many times with FRP tanks, and FRP pump tanks were supplied in 2019 and 2021. Resin, corrosion barrier and temperature are confirmed for each service.
Does outdoor FRP pipe and duct need UV protection?
Yes. Unprotected surfaces degrade in sunlight, starting at field joints and repairs. Specify an exterior UV-resistant coating, including field joints, and use a different colour for each service so lines can be traced.
Why do FRP lines need expansion joints at pumps?
Without them, pump vibration and water hammer at start-up are carried into the FRP line and damage it. Fit expansion joints on both sides of each pump and, where the layout requires, at changes of direction.
What should an FRP purchase package require from the supplier?
A named design, fabrication and inspection standard with its edition, the quality-control records and inspection forms to be submitted before shipment, the agreed hold points, and a defects warranty.
Are bolted vertical seams acceptable in an FRP vessel?
They are a weak point. At PASAR, steel inserts and bolts in a settler’s vertical seams corroded and the seams split. Specify laminated joints with corrosion barrier over the internal seams.
Is FRP grating better than steel deck plate in acid areas?
Where acid or water can pond, moulded FRP grating avoids the corrosion that destroys steel plate and lets liquid drain. Grating heights such as 25, 38, 40 and 50 mm are selected for the span and load.